The Keller Insurance Group

Call Now!


Who we are

The Keller Insurance Group, with headquarters at 2706 Pine Avenue, Niagara Falls, New York has been helping protect individuals and businesses in Western New York for over 50 years. We currently service the insurance needs of over 20,000 individuals and families, and over 8,000 businesses. In an industry that has become highly automated and impersonal, we at The Keller Group continue to provide high-quality, personal, friendly customer service to our clients. Instead of doing business with an answering machine overseas or by just filling out forms on the internet, you can do business face-to-face with an agent that knows you and understands your needs. We represent a large selection of Insurance Carriers and offer competitive pricing and comprehensive coverage that more-often-than-not beats the competition and direct mammoth online providers. Our customers enjoy great rates; exceptional, friendly service; and a huge selection of effective products from multiple insurance carriers. We pride ourselves on our ability to form strong and long lasting relationships with our clients, who become our friends. Because of this, you can rest assured that, should an incident occur, someone you know and trust will be there to help you through it. That’s the Keller promise.

The Keller Group offers the following products:

  • Automobile Insurance
  • Motorcycle Insurance
  • Homeowners Insurance
  • Renters Insurance
  • Commercial and Business Insurance
  • Surety
  • Professional Liability
  • Workers Compensation
  • Specialty Insurance (ATV, Snowmobile, RV and Watercraft)
  • Roadside Service
  • Notary Public
  • Plus much more!

The Keller Group recently merged with the following agencies in 2012 - 2016:

  • AA Insurance Agency – Co-located with CW Baker Insurance Agency at 53 Walnut Street, Lockport NY 14094
  • Action Auto Insurance Agency - 2817 Genesee Street Cheektowaga, NY 14225
  • Bower Insurance Agency – 5668 South Transit Road, Lockport NY 14094
  • Coppola & JEM Insurance Agency – 3625 Seneca Street, West Seneca NY 14224
  • Cannello Insurance Agency – Co-located with Keller at 2706 Pine Avenue, Niagara Falls NY 14301
  • Bronkie Agency - 5813 Main Street, Williamsville, NY 14221
  • CW Baker Insurance Agency- 53 Walnut Street, Lockport NY 14094
  • The Insurance Market Agency - 83 Seymour Street, Tonawanda NY, 14150
  • Lewiston Insurance Agency – 411 Center Street, Lewiston NY 14092
  • DeFranco Insurance Agency – Co-located with Keller at 2706 Pine Avenue, Niagara Falls NY 14301
  • Schunke Insurance Agency - 997 Union Road, West Seneca, NY 14224
  • prague Insurance Agency - 34 W. Market Street, Corning NY 14830

Our staff will work hard to earn and continue deserving your business. Call us today and see what The Keller Group can do for you!

The Keller Insurance Group is proud to be part of Freeway Insurance Services of New York, Inc. which is one of the largest privately-owned insurance brokers in New York with over 62 locations and 225 professionals across the state. The combined company prides itself by offering great coverage rates and exceptional customer service. Our staff is professionally trained and ready to provide you with a personalized policy no matter your driving record, financial situation or risk profile.

Freeway Insurance Services of New York’s parent company, Confie Seguros, is a rapidly growing national provider of personal lines insurance and recently was ranked #5 in revenues in Insurance Journal’s latest top 100 ranking of privately held insurance agencies for 2015.